Friday, May 13, 2011

Day 49 - What Sociologists (and I) say about "The Looking Glass Self"


Mother Combing Child's Hair, Mary Cassatt, 1879
I am a Sociologist (at least in practice if not yet by doctoral degree).  As such, my first "academic" post needed to draw from one of Sociology's most famous theorists: Charles Horton Cooley.  Here goes!

In his book On Self and Social Organization, Cooley develops the aptly phrased (for our purposes) theory of "The Looking Glass Self."  Cooley's theory proposes that our sense of self is forged through our imagination of the way we appear in the eyes of others.  In other words, we are fundamentally social creatures who depend on interactions with others to provide feedback, telling us both who we are and how we should feel about ourselves.

Using mirrors as both metaphor and tool to explain how we see ourselves through other people, Cooley writes:
A social self of this sort might be called the reflected or looking glass self: 
'Each to each a looking-glass
Reflects the other that doth pass.'
As we see our face, figure and dress in the glass, and are interested in them because they are ours, and pleased or otherwise with them according as they do or do not answer to what we should like them to be; so in imagination we perceive in another's mind some thought of our appearance, manners, aims, deeds, character, friends, and so on...."
Thus, even when we look into a mirror, our understanding of what we see is fundamentally social because it is mediated by reactions to us that we have seen in people we spend time with.  As Cooley aptly puts it, "The thing that moves us to pride or shame is not the mere mechanical reflection of ourselves, but [...] the imagined effect of this reflection upon another's mind."

Take a second peek at the child featured in the Mary Cassatt drawing I selected to headline this post.  By Cooley's logic, this child's self image will be more fundamentally shaped by interactions she has with her mother than by the image of herself that she sees reflected in the mirror.  Indeed, it is only through social interactions with mom (and others, obviously!) that a mirrored reflection can have any meaning at all!

Despite focusing on the impact of social interaction, this theory speaks volumes to how mirrors, themselves, contribute to our self-image.  On the one hand, in the purist form of Cooley's theory mirrors are wholly unnecessary for understanding ourselves, so long as we have other people around.  If the people we spend time with see us (and treat us) with love, affection, and approval... we will love, have affection for, and approve of, ourselves.  If the people we spend time with see us (and treat us) with disdain, disrespect, and condescension, well.... you get the picture.

On the other hand, mirrors allow us to actually see (at least in reverse reflection) what others are viewing when they look upon us.  They add another step of self-awareness (and, importantly, a tool for self-adjustment) in this process of self-understanding.  As noted by Autumn Whitefield-Madrano, in her blog The Beheld, mirrors give us greater information (we think) about how people view us.  (Like me, Autumn is partaking in a "mirror-fast.") Based on Autumn's experiences, a look in the mirror before leaving home can inform how we interpret interactions with other people.   Upon being peered at by a stranger on the subway - during her mirror-fast - she writes:
I had no anchor to hold onto, no private feeling of, "Well, I do look nice today" or "I wish he would stop staring at the enormous pimple on my chin."  Without having any idea what he might be seeing, I had no idea how I should feel about him looking at me.
What I love about this passage is that it goes further than Cooley's theory.  It illustrates a cycle in which (1) interactions with people inform how we will view ourselves in a mirror and (2) the mirror, in turn, informs how we understand our interactions with other people.

So far in my mirror-less project, I have been quite blessed to be spending time with people who almost uniformly "reflect" positive things back to me.  Yes, they let me know when I have mascara on my nose (thanks Mandy!), but this is different from expressing disapproval (or disgust, for that matter).  I've learned that others tend to be much kinder to me than I typically am to myself.

I think that this bodes well for my upcoming 10 months without mirrors - so long as I continue to surround myself with people who see (and in doing so, bring out) the best in me.  :)

Next up: I'll let you know what it feels like to go through "mirror-withdrawal".  Soon after, we'll learn explore history of how mirrors have shaped the body image of American girls since the 1830s, from Joan Jacobs Brumberg's awesome book The Body Project.  I'm pretty psyched - hope you are too!



***Like this post?  Subscribe to Mirror, Mirror... OFF The Wall via RSS feed or Email!***

44 comments:

  1. Kjerstin, I am loving your academic takes on mirrors--I'm not an academic and to learn that there are all these theories on mirrors is fascinating. (My boyfriend tweeted about my little-girl-in-mirror post and made a Lacan reference that was totally lost on me...)

    My mother rarely looks in the mirror and once told me that she frequently visualizes herself as looking somewhat like whoever she's talking to. So with my aunt she'll be "thin but weak"; with her father she'll be "old but strong," etc. I think it's impossible to tell how much we really use other people as mirrors to form our self-perception but certainly going a month with only, say, socializing on the telephone or with people who couldn't see me would be a helluva lot harder than this project, ha!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oy, yes Lacan references are generally lost on me also! Glad this academic bit was not too dense to enjoy.

    Your mom has a really unique approach to mirrors vs. people. You should ask her if she intentionally spends more time with people who "reflect" things she especially likes!

    ReplyDelete
  3. The story about the woman on a subway reminds me of a day when I flirted, quite successfully, with a guy at a bar. When I came home I realized that I'd forgotten to put on mascara. I was weirdly horrified that I'd acted so confidently sexy without mascara! How had I pulled it off?, I wondered. Why didn't he find me disgusting!? I realized that my attractiveness was tied more to how I acted than I had previously appreciated. Indeed, my perception of myself was greatly influenced by my imagined (and mistaken) memory of my reflection in a mirror that evening.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I find it interested that we become so "horrified" when realizing that we behaved with confidence and daring when unknowingly looking less-than-our-best.

    Yet, it seems that you were primarily mortified because you had acted with such confidence, not simply because you forgot mascara. Had your night been uneventful, I wonder if you would have greeted your face in the mirror with a simple shrug ("Oops - forgot my mascara"), rather than cringing embarrassment.

    Instead, your reaction to the bar-flirtation sounds seems akin to finding out that your fly was unzipped during a presentation, or that you had spinach in your teeth during a job interview. I think that our self-imposed rules for acceptable appearance can feel even more rigid than more "official" rules. Perhaps this is because we build beauty routines around our appearance, which sets us up to feel unhinged if we deviate from these routines without realizing it. Food for thought!

    ReplyDelete
  5. i think wat makes us so self conscious is wat we think other people will think of our appearance. but honestly "even tho i am very self conscious" we will most likely never know wat they are thinking so there is really nothing to be afraid of. even tho i am thinking this i can never stop asking my sister if my hair looks ok or if there is makeup under my eyes. i love this experiment u are doing and i hope it goes well!!

    ReplyDelete
  6. Another mascara incident, from a different perspective:
    It was finals week and wanting to give myself the best possible chance of doing well on my Political Science exam, I took special care with my makeup and hair so that my attitude/self-image would be strong & positive.
    Being December, it was snowing, and living about a mile from campus I walked through the snow to campus, went to my seat in the exam room and took the exam.
    After the exams were collected, I lingered to chat with the professor awhile. After that I visited the ladies room and glanced up while washing my hands. To my HORROR, I found that during the walk through the blizzard, my carefully-applied mascara had transferred itself from my eyelashes to my eyelids and cheeks, making me look like a drunk raccoon, and NO ONE, not a classmate or even the professor with whom I'd chatted confidently for 5 or 10 minutes had said anything to me.

    Mirrors have their place. Especially when you can't count on people to tell you your fly is unzipped.

    On the other hand, my self-confidence hadn't been lacking right until I realized my mistake. A quick trip to the ladies room (with its mirrors) on the way into the exam might have solved the problem, but would I have felt any more or less confident while chatting with the professor?

    ReplyDelete
  7. This particular is among the the majority of well-liked options associated with getting rid of attention totes. It is utilized in prada replica handbags as well as therapeutic massage parlors. Nevertheless, producing cucumber for the eye can also be very easily carried out at your house. You simply must have the golf slice associated with cucumber as well as input it on your sensitive eye. Should you maintain this inside freezer better still because greatness from the cucumber really can temporarily relieve individuals eye. Actually, Teas totes include coffee that are really full of gucci replica handbags. Antioxidants may reduce the actual swelling from the eye as well as get rid of the darkish arenas as well as lines and wrinkles underneath the eye. These days, there are many lotions currently on the market which particularly focuses on to deal with your skin round the eye. Furthermore, these types of lotions may also gucci replica belts within enhancing good outlines as well as lines and wrinkles round the eye. Eyelastin, Eyevive, Revitalume, Dermalex-MD as well as TNS Enlightening Attention Lotion tend to be a number of the very best items available these days. Individuals have to relaxation. A few is going to be hectic which they are really not really discovering sufficient relaxation prada replica day time. However, attempt to rest together with your mind somewhat raised to lessen liquid storage. Darkish arenas as well as totes underneath the eye tend to be displeasing. It might help to make 1 seem prada replica. To get rid of attention totes, think about the ideas over.

    ReplyDelete
  8. A lot of accouchement acquisition some capacity difficult at one point in time, so you should bethink this. You can try and get your adolescent aback on clue by demography an alive role in helping them by application some tips in this article. Regardless of whether you charge your adolescent to advance grades or abound to be actual acceptable at how to chanel replica get rid of amplitude marks, its important that you accord him/her the absorption needed. A babysitter can sometimes accomplish all the aberration if it comes to making improvements in your childs grades. Usually classrooms arent appropriately able to accord the full bulk of absorption your adolescent needs. Accepting to
    gucci replicaapprentice in a chic of 30 accouchement isnt benign to many kids, abnormally if the accountable they are acquirements a accountable they absolutely attempt with. A able tutor will be alive with your adolescent one on one, and can focus on any specific problems he or she may be having. You are best off allurement your academy about which babysitter is best. A quick seek on the internet will accompany up a account of hermes replica bounded tutors. There was analysis done on belief and alert to music to actuate whether you can advice your academician plan bigger by alert to it. A scattering of scientists will actually say that you can advance how acute you are by alert to assertive types of music. The name given to this abstraction is the Mozart Effect, and you ability be able to use it for your children. Mostly people accept acclimated classical music to advance their focus, but you may not acquisition it so louis vuitton replica simple to allocution yourchildren into alert to it! But you can try to animate your accouchement by artlessly abrogation it arena in the accomplishments if they are accomplishing their studying. To enhance this aftereffect even more, you may wish to assurance them up for music lessons. These altered compassionate programs could possibly be about how to get rid of amplitude marks fast or any added topic. Goals are a abundant way to actuate adults and children to become added motivated and to do better. In commendations to school, accomplish things bigger for your adolescent by creating goals. This has to be something thats both accessible and specific. For example, if your son has been declining at Math, dont try to set a ambition of accepting a 100% on his next test, as thats not actual realistic. Accepting your adolescent to artlessly canyon their next analysis is a bigger goal. If your adolescent accomplishes one ambition you can set some bigger ones. Ambience goals isnt bound to continued term things, you can aswell set goals for day to day things like commutual a analysis paper. Accepting accouchement in the addiction of ambience goals can advice accomplish them added cocky motivated. There are lots of things that must be done to advice your adolescent with school. Every adolescent is different, so they will all accept altered reasons for acute assistance. The affidavit may alter from artlessly not accepting a acceptable diet to blockage up too late. You accept to breitling replica accordingly plan out what the botheration could be. And finally, to accomplish the changes you charge to allocution with your adolescent to aftermath a plan. Go advanced and actuate your adolescent central the best accessible way because thats how you will be abiding he/she excells in how to get rid of amplitude marks.





    ReplyDelete
  9. All India packers and movers list – You will find here best packers and movers website list. If you want to shift your home and office you can click below link and vist website.
    Noida packers and movers
    Delhi packers and movers
    Gurgaon packers and movers
    Faridabad packers and movers
    Packers and movers Indirapuram Ghaziabad
    Delhi movers and packers

    ReplyDelete
  10. A monetary record, as to a private financial specialist credit, is regularly neglected by numerous little agents. It is basic that you showcase the greater part of your benefits, current fleeting liabilities, and whatever other remarkable advance that your business may have when you exhibit your business to a private financial specialist or private bank. Auto Title Loans Chicago

    ReplyDelete
  11. As a result of this, the capacity of families to get ideal terms for thee advances depends using a loan scores. The straightforward application process for these credits has driven numerous understudies to depend solely on private subsidizing and overlook every single other alternative. payday loans chula-vista

    ReplyDelete
  12. This is a significant responsibility, and understudies ought to think precisely before requesting that somebody turn into a cosigner. The cosigner status does not as a matter of course keep going for the life of bank credits. A few organizations permit graduates who have made a specific number of installments to apply to discharge the cosigner from their commitment. Check Cashing Lemon-Grove

    ReplyDelete
  13. Government supported advances executed through the Federal Family Education Loan Program (FFELP) and by and large convey settled, low financing costs; Perkins and Stafford Subsidized advances are need based while Stafford Unsubsidized and PLUS credits are not require based; but rather don't by and large take care of related expenses of training, for example, educational cost, books, PCs, board and everyday costs and so forth. check cashing

    ReplyDelete
  14. Private understudy advances are subsidized and managed by banks and other budgetary foundations. These banks give understudy advances at a higher financing cost contrasted with government understudy advances. Some regular understudy advances accessible are from Citibank and Sallie Mae. cash advance

    ReplyDelete
  15. This is the huge preferred standpoint of a PLUS Loan over different sorts of subsidizing. The credit should just be utilized to take care of school expenses for the understudy being referred to. check cashing

    ReplyDelete
  16. Understudy advances with awful credit are accessible in secured and unsecured structures. A kind of insurance, for example, a bit of property, is utilized to secure a credit. In the event that you don't possess any property, you will apply for an unsecured credit. payday loans chula-vista

    ReplyDelete
  17. Regularly enough, elective understudy advances are likewise credit-based, so they may seem harder to acquire than government advances which require no FICO assessment by any means. Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  18. Through a FFEL advance you merge a few credits with different reimbursement plans into one advance, like a solidification advance. In any case, the reimbursements are set up based upon your pay level. Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  19. The sum to be paid back each month if there should be an occurrence of government understudy credit is for the most part low, since the reimbursement arrangement can be extended over a more drawn out day and age, which makes it appropriate for both understudies and guardians. check cashing

    ReplyDelete
  20. The current monetary circumstance is not helping in making school more moderate. The crush on schools and colleges is making expenses increment and in the meantime imminent understudies and their folks are getting themselves less and less arranged to go up against the expenses of school. payday loans chula-vista

    ReplyDelete
  21. Well honestly, there isn't quite a bit of a catch behind understudy credits; it's simply that you need to reimburse understudy advances by paying by portion or at specific due dates for the measure of cash you were lent. Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  22. Finding the best arrangement is your fundamentally objective so the offer with the most reduced rate of enthusiasm with a sensible time for reimbursement will be your best decision. In the event that the advance is a low intrigue yet will take an over the top measure of time to reimburse this is not an extraordinary arrangement. Payday Loans

    ReplyDelete
  23. This would empower one to set aside on time, cash, and exertion and make one feel uncluttered. The rate would likewise not change in the entire span or course of the credit, so one would truly know the installment to expect and would truly have the capacity to get ready installment early without apprehension of having a higher add up to pay than the one stipulated. check cashing

    ReplyDelete
  24. Despite the fact that, you will discover some understudy credits that don't have that decision, so you should ensure how it stands when you get your undergrad bank advance. There are different choices which are realistic for postponements furthermore the accessibility of getting one. www.aaa1autotitleloans.com/chicago

    ReplyDelete
  25. Similarly as with every individual advance, you should meet some essential capabilities. You should be beyond eighteen years old. You should either be a subject of the United States or be a lawful perpetual inhabitant. payday loans

    ReplyDelete
  26. While Swatch didn’t have to advertise Replica Watches (try to remember the last ad for a watch you saw), the more expensive brands did. Replica handbags Each brand – most now owned by either Swatch Group or Richemont – Replica watches UK positioned itself in a different niche. Breitling aimed for the clouds with photos of handbag replica jet plans and steely-eyed John Travolta. Omega advertised at sporting events where the monied gathered and talked up the fact that it was an Rolex Daytona .

    ReplyDelete
  27. (Salon International de la Haute Horlogerie), Replica watches UK I did see wonderfully refined and equally impressive technical watches, but the vast majority of talking pieces from Replica Watches the exhibiting brands were large, complicated and really, really expensive.A. Lange & Sohne – in my opinion one of handbag replica the finest watch manufactures in the world today – showed its hotly anticipated Zeitwerk Minute Repeater. Replica handbags A minute repeater is the most regal of Rolex Daytona .

    ReplyDelete